Categories

  • No categories

Restaurant Menu

Taste local eatery at it’s best.

Custom dishes and friendly favorites.

The Elusive Cow only uses the freshest of ingredients and organic whenever it’s possible.  Our meats come from local farmers in Brown and Adam’s County, Ohio and our Bison is from Oldham County, Kentucky.  

There’s sure to be more than one favorite.

Appetizers and Salads from our kitchen.

Starters

All of our appetizers are made to order. We use the freshest of ingredients.

Free-Range Chicken Wings (per 6)

Over a pound per 6, these large and tender wings are sure to please! Homemade Sauces: Garlic, Spicy Garlic, Jamaican Jerk, Medium, and Inferno! 12 wings for $17.50 or 18 wings for $26.25.

$8.75
``Traditional`` Flat Bread Pizza

Crispy flat bread covered with our house made marinara, smoked mozzarella, onions & a pepper medley. Add Pulled Smoked Chicken or Pork, Bacon for an additional $3.00.

$8.50
Caprese Flat Bread Pizza

Pesto, Smoked Mozzarella, Roma Tomatoes, Arugula, Balsamic Reduction, Add Pulled Smoked Chicken or Pork, Bacon for an additional $3.00.

$10.95
Portabella Fries

A generous portion of Portabella caps dunked in an herb beer battered and fried served with a side of Cajun Remoulade.

$9.00
Loaded Fries

Our hand cut fries topped with cheddar, applewood smoked bacon & green onions. Served with Sour Cream. Add Chicken for $3.00, Portabella Mushroom or our Mushroom Medley for $2.50, or Caramelized Onions for $1.75.

$9.95
Nachos

Seasoned white corn tortillas, topped with organic black beans, cheddar cheese and pico served with sour cream and house made salsa. (Add Smoked Chicken or Pulled Pork for $3)

$8.95
Onion Rings

Breaded to order in organic cornmeal, flour and spices, then fried golden brown.

$7.00
Sweet Potato Chips

Fresh and crispy, seasoned Sweet Potato Chips.

$4.75
Hummus Plate

Hummus with a mixture of olives, feta cheese, pita and rosemary olive oil.

$9.95
Soup

House-made soups Ask your server to see what we have today! (Choose from a cup or a bowl)

$4.75 / $5.75

Fresh Salads

In our house salads you will find fresh, organic ingredients.
DRESSINGS: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Roasted Pecan/Shallot, Sun-Dried Tomato, House Vinaigrette

Small House Green Salad

Organic greens, shredded carrots, grape tomatoes, cucumbers and red onion.

$5.25
Full House Green Salad

Organic Greens, shredded carrots, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, rod onions, kalamata olives & artichoke hearts.

$7.95
Full House Spinach Salad

Organic spinach, shredded carrots, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives & artichoke hearts

$9.25

Locally farm raised meats from the tri-county area.

Sandwiches & Entrees

Sandwiches

All Burgers and sandwiches topped with green-leaf lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, and salt-brined pickles.

Classic Burgers

All Burgers and sandwiches topped with green-leaf lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, and salt-brined pickles.

Add-On Items
Choose Your Cheese: $1.00 each for Cheddar, Swiss, Dill Havarti, Smoked Gouda, Provolone, Vegan Cheddar, or Vegan Mozzarella. $1.50 for Blue Cheese Crumbles.

Choose your bread: French Roll, Flaxseed or Rye Bread, Udi’s® Gluten Free Buns.

Other Toppings: $1.75 each for Bacon, Avocado, Caramelized Onions, Artichoke Hearts, or Sun-Dried Tomatoes. $2.50 each for Portabella Mushroom Cap or Mushroom Medley, $2.75 for Seitan Bacon.

Free-Range Chicken Sandwich

Fresh from the arm chicken breast – wither pan-seared or fried.

$9.75
Chicken Salad Sandwich

Same great chicken, diced and tossed with celery, onions, walnuts, fresh herbs and red peppers. Served on a buttery croissant.

$9.75
NY Strip Steak Sandwich

Strips of NY Strip Steak, pilled high and topped with caramelized onions, red & gold peppers. Add cheese and mushrooms if you’d like that Philly style!*

$9.95
Pulled Pork Sandwich

Smoked pulled pork, served with our house made BBQ. Served on bread of your choosing and it comes with one side choice.

$9.95
Ultimate BLT

Four strips of smoked bacon (vegan options available*), avocado and of course green leaf lettuce and roma tomatoes make this one delicious sandwich. Served with a side of your choosing.

$9.95
Smoked Turkey Sandwich

Our own slow-smoked free range turkey breast, topped with avocado, served on 16 Bricks Challah Bread with a side of your choosing.*

$9.75
Reuben

Thin slices of corn beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut from the Pickled Pig served on 16 Bricks Rye Bread, served with Cajun Remoulade and a side of your choosing.*

$11.00
Cod Sandwich

Choose either pan-seared or fried. This tender, moist and flakey fish is sure to please!

$9.75

Vegetarian Sandwiches

A delicious alternative! All vegetarian sandwiches are topped with green-leaf lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, and salt-brined pickles.

Add-On Items
Choose Your Cheese: $1.00 each for Cheddar, Swiss, Dill Havarti, Smoked Gouda, Provolone, Vegan Cheddar, or Vegan Mozzarella. $1.50 for Blue Cheese Crumbles.

Choose your bread: French Roll, Flaxseed or Rye Bread, Udi’s® Gluten Free Buns.

Other Toppings: $1.75 each for Bacon, Avocado, Caramelized Onions, Artichoke Hearts, or Sun-Dried Tomatoes. $2.50 each for Portabella Mushroom Cap or Mushroom Medley, $2.75 for Seitan Bacon.

Veggie Burger

We must confess that it’s a THE BEYOND BURGER® , however we sear it with our own brand of spices to give it a great taste!

$8.75
Portabella Sandwich

A nice sized portabella mushroom (two if they run small) marinated and seared until tender.

$8.75
Veggie Wrap

A blend of mushrooms, onions, red & gold peppers and a blend of herbs and spices. Wrapped into a whole wheat tortilla shell. Add chicken or pork if you ‘d like for $3.00.

$8.75
Tempeh Sliders

Two marinated tempeh patties, seared and served on classic style slider buns. Seitan Bacon available for additional charge.

$8.75
Falafel Pita

Three house-made falafel patties folded into a whole wheat pita and topped with diced green-leaf lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, pickles, black olives and artichoke hearts. Served with our cashew cream tzatziki sauce.

$9.25
Mozzarella, Plum Tomato & Pesto

Fresh mozzarella, ripe plumb tomatoes, balsamic reduction, arugula and our house made pesto are layered between fresh french bread and pressed until the cheese is warm and melted. Served with a side of your choosing.

$9.25
Add-On Items
Choose Your Cheese: $1.00 each for Cheddar, Swiss, Dill Havarti, Smoked Gouda, Provolone, Vegan Cheddar, or Vegan Mozzarella. $1.50 for Blue Cheese Crumbles.

Choose your bread: French Roll, Flaxseed or Rye Bread, Udi’s® Gluten Free Buns.

Other Toppings: $1.75 each for Bacon, Avocado, Caramelized Onions, Artichoke Hearts, or Sun-Dried Tomatoes. $2.50 each for Portabella Mushroom Cap or Mushroom Medley, $2.75 for Seitan Bacon.

Beef Burger

Locally raised Beef, seasoned and cooked to order.

$9.75
Turkey Burger

Free Range Turkey, house seasoned, pan seared to perfection.

$9.50
Bison Burger

Farm raised Bison, seasoned and cooked to order.

$10.75

Entrees

Golden Idaho Trout

A wonderful filet of trout, a light, flakey, mild fish, pan seared and served with a side of your choosing.*

$15.95
Cod Dinner

Tender, flaky, North Atlantic ‘wild caught’ cod, always fresh from Lukens at Findlay Market – fried or pan-seared and served with two side choices.*

$15.95
Organic Scottish Salmon

A beautiful 6oz filet or organic farm raised salmon from Scotland seared and served with a side of your choosing.*

$17.95
Soft Tacos

3 Soft Tacos topped with leaf lettuce & house made Pico De Gallo and served with sides of Lime, Cilantro Sour Cream and Salsa. Add Avocado or Cheese for an additional charge.

Choose from:
Vegetable
Chicken or Pork
Cod or Pick Three

$12.75
$13.75
$14.75

Side Items

    • Hand Cut French Fries
    • Side Salad (Dressings include: ranch, pecan/shallot, blue-cheese, sun-dried tomato or house vinaigrette)
    • Sauteed Kale (red onions, garlic and mushrooms.)
    • Kale Slaw (kale, arugula, green apples and dates in a tangy dressing.)
    • Vegetable of the Day
    • Sweet Potato Chips

Beverages

Soft Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, 7-Up, Ginger Ale, Lemonade, or Mountain Dew

Iced Tea/Hot Tea

All Organic Teas: Organic iced Tea, Earl Grey, Green, Peppermint or Breakfast

Wines

Whites, Reds and more

Coffee

Organic Dark Roasted Mexican (Regular or Decaf)

Beers

Craft Beers, American, National and Local selections.

Liquors

Vodka, Gin, Rum, Bourbon/Whiskey, Tequila, Scotch, Cordials,

Desserts

Desserts

We have some delicious house made desserts on hand. We always try to have something new and seasonal. Just ask your server what we’ve come up with and we’re certain you’ll enjoy!

A variety of Housemade or locally sourced desserts.
$6.00